Dove vs Superhuman: Two Answers to the Same Inbox

Superhuman makes you faster at email. Dove does more of the email for you. Everything else in this comparison follows from that, and you can usually settle it before you’ve read a feature list.

Both apps start from the same complaint: default email is bad enough to pay to fix. Where they part company is what “fixed” looks like. Superhuman hands you a faster set of tools and assumes you’ll be excellent with them. Dove reads what arrived and makes the call, then shows you what it decided.

So this isn’t really a feature bake-off. It’s a question about where your bottleneck sits. If you’re slow at email, Superhuman is a genuinely great purchase. If you’re drowning in email, speed is the wrong lever — two hundred messages at twice the pace is still two hundred messages.

Below: what each app does, what the AI in each one actually decides, where the platform and provider limits fall, how the plans are shaped, and who should pick which.

Key Takeaways

• Superhuman optimises the doing: 100+ keyboard shortcuts, Split Inbox, AI drafts. You still decide what matters.

• Dove decides first. Today assembles your day before you open it, and sorts every message into Needs You, FYI, Waiting on, Noise or Done.

• Superhuman Mail works with Gmail and Outlook only, and Windows users reach it through a browser. Dove adds Yahoo and any IMAP account, with native Mac and Windows apps.

• The plans are shaped differently: Superhuman Mail sells tiers, with its strongest AI above the entry plan. Dove sells one plan. Check both pricing pages for current numbers.

• Superhuman’s parent company rebranded from Grammarly to Superhuman in October 2025. “Superhuman” now names a four-product suite; Superhuman Mail is the email client inside it.

The short version

The table reads better as two philosophies than as a scorecard. Superhuman’s column is full of things you operate. Dove’s column is full of things that have already happened by the time you open the app.

What Superhuman is genuinely good at

Superhuman won its argument. Email clients were slow, mouse-dependent and cluttered, and Superhuman proved a fast one feels like a different category of thing. That reputation was earned, not bought.

The keyboard model is the heart of it: more than 100 shortcuts, a command palette for whatever isn’t bound to a key, and a performance budget strict enough that nothing lags behind your hands. Longtime users talk about muscle memory rather than features, which is the right compliment for a tool like this.

Split Inbox is the other pillar. You define lanes — team mail, VIPs, calendar invites, news — and Superhuman files incoming mail into them, so you process a category at a time instead of a chronological pile. Auto Labels extend that with AI-assigned tags. Both work well.

The part most comparisons skip: those lanes are configuration. Someone has to decide what the categories are, describe them, and revise them when the work changes. That’s a real cost, paid up front and again every few months, and it’s the same cost every rules-based email system has charged since the invention of the mail filter.

If you love keyboard control, live entirely in Gmail, and your honest complaint is that you’re not fast enough at a workflow you already trust, buy Superhuman. It’ll do exactly what you want, and nothing below is likely to change your mind.

The failure mode shows up elsewhere. Someone learns the shortcuts in a fortnight, genuinely halves their time per message, and six months later is still clearing the inbox at 8pm. Speed was never the constraint. The volume arrives whether or not you’re good at it.

Curious what the other approach looks like? See how Dove decides where an email lands.

Where Dove vs Superhuman actually diverges: who does the triage

This is the real fault line, and almost nobody writes it down.

Superhuman: faster tools, same decisions

Superhuman is an excellent instrument, played by you. Split Inbox routes by rules you wrote. Auto Labels tag messages, which helps you find things, but the judgment about what deserves your next 20 minutes stays yours. Ask AI answers when you ask. Auto Drafts write when you prompt them.

All good features. All of them tools waiting for your instruction. The decision layer — the part that actually costs you attention — never leaves your desk. It just gets a better keyboard.

Dove: the decision is already made

Dove works the other way round. It reads everything that arrived and sorts it before you look, into one of five places:

• Needs You — a real person, a real ask, a real deadline. Top of the screen, with what to do next.

• FYI — worth knowing, not worth a reply. One line each.

• Waiting on — you replied, they owe you something. Tracked so it doesn’t quietly lapse.

• Noise — newsletters, promotions, bulk. Out of your day, never deleted.

• Done — off the list.

Above all of it, Today writes your morning in a sentence and rewrites it as the day moves. You don’t open a list and start sorting. You open a day that’s already assembled.

The obvious objection is accuracy, and the answer is correction. Every placement can be corrected, and correcting one teaches Dove what matters to you. Tell it in plain language that mail from your accountant always needs you, and that sticks — on every device, without anyone building a filter. The inbox gets quieter the more you use it.

Worth being clear about what isn’t being claimed here: not that Dove is faster than Superhuman. It probably isn’t. Superhuman is the fastest thing in this category. Dove’s bet is that speed stopped being the constraint somewhere around your hundredth message of the day.

What the AI actually does in each app

Both apps say “AI email”. They mean different jobs.

Superhuman’s AI assists the writing and the finding. Auto Summarize condenses long threads. Ask AI searches your mail conversationally. Auto Drafts compose replies in your voice. Auto Labels classify. It’s a strong, coherent set — and the best of it, Ask AI, Auto Drafts and custom Auto Labels, sits on a higher tier rather than the entry plan.

Dove’s AI does the deciding, then the doing. Three pieces matter:

Wingman reads across threads, not just the open one. That distinction is the whole feature. Say a routine renewal approval lands in your inbox; Wingman can surface the original agreement from a different thread two months earlier and flag that the new quote sits above the rate you signed off. The contradicting fact is almost never inside the thread you’re reading, which is why reading that thread harder doesn’t find it.

Ask Dove turns the answer into the action. Ask what you need to know for Lisbon next week and it tells you the flight lands at 10:40pm while hotel check-in closes at 10, then drafts the late-check-in request. One move, rather than a search result you then go and act on.

Security scoring runs underneath. Every message gets a risk score, and anything dangerous is risk-scored before it reaches you rather than quarantined after the fact.

Put plainly: Superhuman’s AI makes you better at email tasks. Dove’s AI removes email tasks. Both are legitimate products. They aren’t the same product.

Want to see the difference on your own inbox? You can connect an account and watch the triage happen on real mail before you commit to anything. Try Dove.

Accounts, platforms and price

Here’s where the comparison stops being philosophical.

Providers. Superhuman Mail supports Gmail and Outlook. That’s the list. Dove connects Gmail, Outlook, Office 365, Yahoo and any IMAP account, which matters if you run a legacy work domain, a Fastmail account, or anything self-hosted.

Platforms. Superhuman ships native apps for Mac and iOS, plus an Android app for Gmail accounts; Windows users get the browser rather than a dedicated desktop app. Outlook coverage is narrower than Gmail — web, Mac and iOS only. Dove ships iOS, Android, macOS, Windows and Web, and classification happens server-side, so the same assembled day shows up everywhere at once. If you’re a Windows-and-Outlook person, this isn’t a detail. It’s the decision.

Price. The two are packaged differently, so compare shapes before you compare numbers. Superhuman Mail sells tiered plans, with the AI most people want it for — Ask AI, Auto Drafts, custom Auto Labels — and the CRM integrations sitting above the entry tier, and an enterprise tier quoted by sales. Dove sells a single plan with everything in it. Both pricing pages change; check them rather than trusting a figure quoted in a comparison article.

One more thing worth knowing before you buy. Grammarly acquired Superhuman in July 2025, and in October 2025 the parent company rebranded itself to Superhuman. “Superhuman” now names a suite of four products: the Grammarly writing assistant, Superhuman Mail, the Coda workspace, and an agent layer called Superhuman Go. The email client is still there and still shipping. But when you read a review or a pricing page, check which Superhuman it’s describing. A lot of the confusion in current comparison content comes from writers conflating the suite with the mail app.

Which one should you use?

Choose Superhuman if you live in Gmail, you want keyboard control over every action, you’re willing to design and maintain your own Split Inbox categories, and your honest complaint is that email takes too long per message. You’re buying the best-executed version of that idea.

Choose Dove if your complaint is volume rather than speed, you’d rather correct a decision than make one, you need a provider or platform Superhuman doesn’t cover, or you want to open your email and find the day already built instead of a pile to process.

Choose neither if your inbox is quiet. Forty messages a day is a problem free Gmail solves. Both of these are for people whose mail has turned into a second job.

And some people try Dove and go back. If you get 30 emails a day, nearly all from people you know, and you enjoy the keyboard flow, there’s nothing being decided on your behalf that you minded deciding yourself. That’s a correct outcome, not a failure, and any comparison that can’t produce it is selling rather than comparing.

The bottom line on Dove vs Superhuman

Superhuman and Dove solve adjacent problems, which makes them easy to mistake for rivals. Superhuman is the answer to “email is too slow.” Dove is the answer to “email is too much.”

To recap:

• Superhuman gives you faster tools; you keep the triage. Dove does the triage; you keep the corrections.

• Superhuman Mail is Gmail and Outlook only, with no native Windows app. Dove covers any IMAP account on five platforms.

• Superhuman Mail tiers its plans and puts its best AI above the entry tier. Dove sells one plan.

• The Superhuman brand now covers four products. Superhuman Mail is one of them.

Work out which sentence describes your inbox, then buy accordingly. If it’s the second one, Today, Wingman and Ask Dove start working on your real mail within a couple of minutes of connecting an account.

Try Dove → No migration, and it works alongside the account you already have.

FAQ

Is Dove a good alternative to Superhuman?
Depends on your bottleneck. Dove is a strong alternative if email volume is what’s burying you, since it triages every message before you open the app. It’s a weaker one if what you love about Superhuman is keyboard-driven speed, because Dove isn’t trying to win on raw interaction pace.

How do Dove and Superhuman compare on price?
They’re packaged differently. Superhuman Mail sells tiered plans and puts Ask AI, Auto Drafts, custom Auto Labels and its CRM integrations above the entry tier, with enterprise pricing negotiated separately. Dove sells one plan with everything in it. Check both pricing pages for current figures rather than relying on numbers quoted elsewhere.

What happened to Superhuman after Grammarly bought it?
Grammarly acquired Superhuman in July 2025 and then, in October 2025, renamed the whole company Superhuman. The email client is now called Superhuman Mail and sits alongside Grammarly, Coda and Superhuman Go in one suite. The mail app continues to ship.

Does Superhuman work with any email provider?
No. Superhuman Mail supports Gmail and Outlook only, and Outlook coverage is limited to web, Mac and iOS. Dove works with Gmail, Outlook, Office 365, Yahoo and any IMAP account.

What is the difference between AI that sorts your email and AI that writes it?
Sorting AI decides what deserves your attention and in what order; writing AI produces text once you’ve decided to reply. Superhuman leads with writing assistance and lets you configure the sorting. Dove leads with sorting and adds drafting on top. One removes decisions, the other removes typing.

<!-- TODO(editor): embed one relevant YouTube video before publishing. No verified Dove-channel video existed at write time; do not insert an unverified video ID. -->